Major League Soccer · Regular Season - 26
Yankee Stadium · New York
Head to head
- Major League SoccerNew York Red Bulls
1–1
New York City FCSat, May 16, 06:30 PM 
US Open CupNew York Red Bulls1–3New York City FCWed, Apr 29, 06:00 PM- Major League SoccerNew York Red Bulls2–3New York City FCSat, Sep 27, 06:30 PM
- Major League SoccerNew York City FC2–0New York Red BullsSat, May 17, 03:30 PM
- Major League SoccerNew York City FC0–2New York Red BullsSat, Nov 23, 05:30 PM